Planning application ref:
EHDC-25-0748-OUT
156 New Houses will Swamp Holybourne Village
We believe the disproportionate scale of this proposed development will damage Holybourne's village environment and our vibrant community life.
This website sets out our many detailed objections, all of which are based on existing planning policies

HVA Submits Formal Complaint
Date: 8th November 2026
East Hampshire District Council (EHDC) published their Planning Officer's Report, which rejected Redbrown's planning application on the basis that the only issue was that the groundwater risk was not fully understood. All other objections were, in the view of the Holybourne Village Association (HVA), not properly addressed, despite HVA submitting detailed local evidence along with responses from other official consultees.
HVA's view is that this is a major failure of the planning process and has lodged a formal complaint concerning the integrity of the decision record and evidence-handling process.
Our detailed formal complaint runs to over 70 pages and can be viewed here
Below is the Executive Summary, extracted from the full complaint document sent to EHDC on 8th November 2026
Holybourne Village Association’s response to the delegated Officer Report for EHDC-25-0748-OUT
To: East Hampshire District Council
Application: EHDC-25-0748-OUT
Site: Land to the rear of 136–150 London Road, Holybourne
Submitted by: Holybourne Village Association (HVA)
Status: Formal representation and corporate complaint concerning the integrity of the delegated decision record and evidence-handling process
Date: 8 November 2026
Executive Summary
Holybourne Village Association (HVA) does not challenge East Hants District Council’s (EHDC) refusal of planning permission for EHDC-25-0748-OUT.
It challenges the reliability of the affirmative planning case EHDC chose to publish alongside that refusal.
EHDC went substantially beyond identifying sufficient grounds to refuse. The Officer Report concludes that, “were it not for” unresolved groundwater, the benefits would outweigh the harms and the development would represent sustainable development.
That conclusion matters. In practical effect, it leaves behind an apparent roadmap for resubmission:
resolve groundwater → retain the positive findings → approval follows
This submission demonstrates why that proposition is untenable.
EHDC promised the safeguard. The safeguard failed.
HVA raised the evidential risk before determination. EHDC had chosen not routinely to require specialist consultees to engage with HVA's detailed contrary technical evidence. HVA therefore repeatedly asked how consideration of that evidence would be safeguarded.
EHDC's answer was explicit: the case officer and final Officer Report would consider the material planning matters raised, seek further specialist input where necessary, and assess those matters against the Development Plan, national policy and other material considerations. The Chief Planning Officer defended that process. On 10 March 2026, the Monitoring Officer stated “for the avoidance of any doubt” that the Monitoring Officer was satisfied with that position.
EHDC promised the safeguard. The Officer Report was therefore the test of EHDC's own assurance.
It fails that test.
Mentioning an objection is not assessing it. Summarising evidence is not engaging with its substance. Repeating a consultee conclusion does not resolve contrary technical evidence which that consultee was never asked to examine.
And the failure matters because EHDC then relied upon that process to make definitive
affirmative planning judgements.
The failure is structural, not incidental
The problems identified in this submission are not a collection of disagreements about
planning weight.
They recur across the Officer Report:
-
Adopted spatial strategy: Holybourne remains Tier 4, yet EHDC imports Alton's Tier 1 jobs, services and sustainability credentials into the case for major development at Holybourne, reproducing the central logic of the abandoned Regulation 18 “Alton (including Holybourne)” strategy which the Report itself says carries no weight.
-
NPPF Policy S5(1)(j): housing need is allowed to do work which separate gateway requirements for physical relationship, scale and infrastructure still had to perform.
-
Infrastructure: HCC says Montecchio is already close to theoretical capacity and that no deliverable engineering intervention can meaningfully increase vehicular capacity; NHS evidence says existing GP practices cannot absorb the additional patients. EHDC nevertheless concludes that infrastructure capacity is satisfied through contributions and conditions.
-
Accessibility: EHDC measures from Montecchio rather than the development, accepts that even that shorter journey to Alton is probably further than most people would walk, and then relies upon a rural-walking assumption contradicted by its own commissioned accessibility evidence.
-
Highways: development-required mitigation is rebadged as an LCWIP public benefit, while parking displacement identified by HCC is never demonstrably traced through to its consequences for the existing village.
-
Neighbourhood Plan: EHDC acknowledges the made Alton Neighbourhood Plan and additional S6 protection, yet omits CH5, the policy protecting the Local Green Space, from its ANP policy assessment while deploying an indicative housing figure which EHDC's own guidance says is not a housing requirement.
-
Village facilities: EHDC counts Holybourne's existing facilities once to establish sustainability and again to claim a positive economic benefit from 156 additional households. Yet when the people actually running and using those facilities explained how the development's own highway mitigation could damage their accessibility, operation and trade, the Officer Report did not resolve that contrary evidence. The facilities are counted when they support the positive case; the evidence from those facilities is not equivalently engaged with when it undermines it.
-
Local Green Space: EHDC constructs a route through NPPF Policy GB7 which the policy does not contain, fails that route on its own findings, does not undertake the alternative GB6 very-special-circumstances exercise, but nevertheless proceeds to an ordinary planning balance anyway. That is not an exercise of planning judgment within the policy. It is a misapplication of the policy itself.
-
Heritage: EHDC's own pre-2023 evidence had identified heritage as a constraint on strategic development. Its Conservation Officer identified the harm again and objected. Historic England identified continuing harm and left the balance to EHDC. Yet the Officer Report does not perform the complete asset-specific HE5/HE6 exercise and ultimately balances an incomplete heritage case away against housing. That is not simply a difference of planning judgement over heritage weight. It is a misapplication of the heritage policy framework: EHDC undertook the balance before completing the assessment required to establish what it was balancing.
-
Inspector evidence: Inspector reasoning submitted by HVA disappears from the substantive assessment while Buntingford is expressly interpreted and deployed where EHDC considers it supportive.
-
Planning balance: individual harms are repeatedly neutralised against selected benefits before the purported cumulative balance is reached. That is not the way the cumulative planning balance should be exercised.
The pattern is consistent: where policy, evidence or local experience obstructs the positive case, the Officer Report variously ignores it, records it without substantive engagement, leaves it unresolved, or constructs a route around it. Where contrary community evidence should test that route, the promised safeguard does not
demonstrate equivalent scrutiny.
The Inspector evidence provides the simplest audit test: HVA submitted it and identified the propositions for which it was relied upon; the Officer Report does not even acknowledge it. Buntingford, by contrast, is expressly identified, interpreted and deployed where EHDC considers its reasoning supportive. That is not even-handed evidence handling.
Bentley makes that failure impossible to dismiss as oversight. It was EHDC's own near-contemporaneous application of the same adopted spatial strategy, reaching materially contrary conclusions on settlement role, scale, countryside function and the proposition that housing need does not override those constraints. HVA repeatedly put Bentley before EHDC and required it to follow or materially distinguish its reasoning.
The Officer Report does neither. EHDC deploys Buntingford when Inspector reasoning assists its positive case; Bentley, its own materially contrary comparator, simply disappears.
The “were it not for groundwater” conclusion is consequently unreliable
The Officer Report's final conclusion is not demonstrated to arise from a fresh cumulative assessment of a complete adverse case.
By the time EHDC reaches the final balance, agricultural harm has already been outweighed; landscape harm has already been outweighed; heritage harm has already been outweighed; Local Green Space harm has been paired against replacement recreation; development mitigation has become positive highway weight; and
Development Plan conflict has been set aside against housing need.
Groundwater is left standing after almost everything else has already been analytically and individually dispatched.
Worse, several of those adverse exercises were themselves incomplete. EHDC was repeatedly deploying the positive case against an adverse case which, in material respects, it had not finished identifying.
The final counterfactual conclusion is therefore not a safe finding that everything except groundwater is acceptable.
It is the residue left after serial neutralisation and a lack of meaningful engagement with
the counter case.
This is now a corporate governance failure
The local community engaged extensively and in good faith with the process EHDC provided. It submitted technical evidence, policy analysis and Inspector decisions; updated its case as applicant evidence and national policy changed; identified procedural concerns before determination; and escalated those concerns precisely so
EHDC could prevent this outcome.
EHDC defended its process.
The Monitoring Officer endorsed the safeguard.
The completed Officer Report is now the manifestation of whether that safeguard actually operated as promised. It failed.
That sits directly against EHDC's own Council Strategy commitment to greater community participation and agency, and to being transparent, reliable, accountable and engaging, with residents' best interests kept “at the heart of planning”. The Community’s experience of this planning application process has been anything but.
Those commitments have to mean more than allowing residents to upload documents.
Participation without substantive engagement is not agency.
Receipt without assessment is not accountability.
A promised safeguard which the final decision record does not demonstrate is not transparency.
The refusal is the decision.
The additional counterfactual narrative is not a permission, not a comprehensive determination that every non-groundwater issue is acceptable, and not a roadmap to approval.
HVA does not invite EHDC to repair the Officer Report retrospectively.
The Report is the Report. The safeguard failed. The affirmative conclusion that, “were it not for” unresolved groundwater, the benefits would outweigh the harms and the development would represent sustainable development cannot survive that failure. It is the product of the defective process identified throughout this complaint. It cannot properly stand as a bank of favourable findings or a roadmap to approval.
East Hants Refuses Redbrown Application
Date: 26th October 2026
East Hants District Council's (EHDC) draft Planning Officer's report has now been finalised and it has refused the Redbrown planning application for 156 houses, principally due to the unresolved level of groundwater flood risk.
The Holybourne Village Association (HVA) issued this statement today:
"The Redbrown proposal for a large housing estate in the village of Holybourne has been refused by East Hampshire District Council planners due to concerns about the unknown nature of the groundwater flood risk.
This decision was made following repeated concerns by local residents that the proposed development site would be on land with high groundwater and active seasonal springs and streams. Our local knowledge, including videos of previous groundwater flooding and the mapping of local springs, questioned the data and conclusions of both the hydrogeological assessment and the Flood Risk Assessment commissioned by the developers Redbrown.
These concerns were raised with both Hampshire County Council and EHDC and led them to commission an independent review of the original Hydrogeological survey, which highlighted significant errors in both the methodology of the original survey and its omission of other relevant local spring areas on the site. This means that the groundwater flood risk has not been properly assessed, rendering Redbrown's current flood mitigation proposals insufficient and inadequate. (View a summary of the assessment here).
On this basis, Hampshire County Council's local flood team were unable to approve Redbrown's flood management proposals and so the outline planning permission was subsequently refused by East Hampshire's planning officers.
However, whilst welcoming this decision, the Holybourne Village Association continues to challenge East Hampshire's responses to their other substantive objections, namely the disproportionate parking restrictions that would threaten village community life, the loss of a cherished and widely-used local green space (Holybourne Play Park), the damage to Holybourne's Conservation Area and the negative visual impact on the exceptional Hampshire Downs landscape.
At this time, we believe Redbrown has not publicly responded to the refusal but should they do so, the HVA will respond as required."
Independent Groundwater Expert Review - View the full report here
To view the final Planning Officer's report, click here
About Us
The Holybourne Village Association (HVA) has represented our community since 1972. All villagers are automatically members and can participate in any aspect of our activities. The views expressed here are those of the HVA committee.
Contact us: planning@holybourne.com